Welcome to Petey's Pizza & Carry Out
Petey's Pizza & Carry Out, located in Arcanum, Ohio, is a beloved gem known for its outstanding pizza and subs. Nestled along US-127, this establishment shines with its inviting atmosphere and exceptional service. Patrons rave about the diverse menu, featuring crowd favorites like the Supreme and Meat Lovers pizzas, as well as the acclaimed Taco pizza that leaves a lasting impression. Customers praise the friendly staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant experience. Whether you’re passing through or a local, Petey's promises a delightful feast that will make any pizza lover's heart sing.
Petey's Pizza & Carry Out: Reviews & Ratings
The best pizza and subs!! Staff is amazing. Friendly and courteous. Would highly recommend.
We usually get Supreme or Meat lovers pizzas. Tonight we tried the taco pizza. It exceeded our expectations. Great pizzas guys keep it up.
Some of the best pizza that I've ever had. The service is great they even held the door for me and helped carry out my pizzas. I highly recommend this place if your passing by.
I grew up eating, and still haven't found anything better than Petey's Taco Pizza's. This pizza is pretty much the only reason I would consider returning to Ohio. The owner was always amazing. Can someone figure out a delivery method that can get this to the southern coast?
We weren’t sure about this place because it seemed to be in the middle of nowhere. Yet, the phone rang off the hook, if that tells you anything!! Even though they weren’t set up well for dining in, staff was completely accommodating and super nice. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!
Pizza is always excellent and tasty, pleasant personnel
Great pizza and great people. What more can I say. I like the deluxe pizza and this is normally an every Friday evening treat. I normally pick up the pizza due to the extra 5 dollar up charge. That 5 dollar upcharge does not go to the driver. So delivery ends up costing 10 dollars after the tip for delivery. Just making sure people know the up charge does not go to the driver.
I love Petey's pizza have been eating it for about 30 years.. Moved away an when I came home for visits I always got a Petey's pizza delivered and it's as good now as.it was when I was a kid..
Location
-
2494 US-127, Arcanum, OH 45304, United States Hotline: +1 937-692-8384
Welcome to the hidden gem of Arcanum, Ohio—Petey's Pizza & Carry Out, where every slice tells a story and every bite transports you to pizza paradise. Located conveniently at 2494 US-127, this delightful establishment has garnered a loyal following, and for good reason. With a phone call away at +1 937-692-8384, it's never been easier to indulge in a savory experience that resonates with both locals and travelers alike.
What makes Petey's stand out in the pizza landscape? The answer lies not just in their menu, but in their commitment to exceptional service and delightful culinary creations. Loyal patrons rave about their pizzas, especially the Supreme and Meat Lovers, which have become fan favorites. Adventurous souls can also try the surprisingly delightful Taco Pizza, which reviewers like Ron Ron describe as exceeding expectations with every slice. The craftsmanship that goes into each pie is evident, showcasing a dedication to quality ingredients and innovative flavor combinations.
But it’s not just about the pizza. Petey’s caters to the craving for mouthwatering subs that pack a punch of flavor, keeping the culinary experience well-rounded. The warmth of the staff adds to the appeal, as seen in heartwarming reviews from customers like Vicky Ahlering-Flory, who highlights the friendliness and courtesy of the team. Imagine being greeted with a smile, a door held open, and support in carrying out your pizzas—it's these small touches that transform a meal into a memorable experience.
Even if the location may seem unassuming, Louisa “Louie” Costello emphasizes that the bustling phone line and supportive staff speak volumes about the local love for Petey's. This is a place where the community gathers, making it a must-stop for anyone passing through. And for those who share Timothy Franklin's nostalgic connection to Petey's Taco Pizza, it’s clear that this establishment holds a special place in the hearts of many. One bite, and you may find yourself wishing for delivery options to bring Petey’s incredible offerings straight to your door—no matter where life takes you.
So, whether you’re a long-time local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Petey's Pizza & Carry Out for a delicious experience that transcends the ordinary. Trust the reviews, heed the recommendations, and get ready to enjoy some of the best pizza in Ohio. You won't regret it.